Most Active Stories
- Scott MacKay Commentary: Providence Journal, We Knew Ye Well
- A.H. Belo Hires Arkansas Firm to Explore Sale of the Providence Journal
- TGIF: 12 Things to Know About Rhode Island Politics + Media
- This I Believe Rhode Island: Getting Up Early
- Prescription Drug Abuse On The Rise On College Campuses Across The Country
Shots - Health News
Mon May 27, 2013
Overweight People Are More Apt To Ditch Doctors
Originally published on Tue May 28, 2013 8:08 am
Patients struggling with obesity can have a tough time finding the right doctor, according to researchers at Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine.
"Patients often complain that their primary care doctor is too judgmental or harsh with them about their weight," says Dr. Kimberly Gudzune, an internal medicine physician at Johns Hopkins. She sees lots of overweight and obese patients who want to lose weight, but feel that their doctor isn't supporting them in that effort. Because of that, she says, patients want to find another doctor. And they often do.
That prompted Gudzune to do a study to see whether this was a trend. She looked at medical records of more than 20,000 people enrolled in a single health insurance plan. She compared how often patients switched doctors. Switching doctors more than five times over two years was considered "doctor shopping," which correlates with less preventive medicine and continuity of care.
It turned out overweight patients doctor-shopped 23 percent more than patients of normal weight. Obese patients sought out new doctors at a rate 52 percent higher than that of normal weight patients. The results were published in the journal Obesity.
This study couldn't say why these patients switched doctors so much. But Gudzune says that other research finds that primary care settings can be uncomfortable for overweight patients. Staff can be judgmental. And equipment, like blood pressure cuffs and exam tables, is often too small.
If patients don't have a stable primary care provider, they are more likely to end up in the hospital ER when they have a problem. And that's exactly what Gudzune found. In her study, overweight and obese patients were 80 percent more likely to go to the hospital emergency room than were normal weight patients.
"Interestingly, they did not have increased rates of hospitalization over that period, which suggests to me that these patients were using the emergency room potentially for conditions that really didn't need the emergency room," Gudzune says.
Other studies have found that not only are ER visits more costly than visits with a primary care doctor, but patient health can be compromised. According to Gudzune, "patients who have the same doctor are less likely to need to use the emergency room; they're also more likely to get all of their preventive health screens such as breast cancer screening or colon cancer screening."
Bottom line, says Gudzune: Improved communication between doctors and patients could make a big difference not only in patient health but also in helping patients lose weight.
DAVID GREENE, HOST:
Now patients struggling with obesity can often have a tough time finding the right doctor. NPR's Patti Neighmond reports on new research from Johns Hopkins University that shows overweight patients are more likely to doctor shop.
PATTI NEIGHMOND, BYLINE: Researchers describe doctor shopping as switching doctors more than five times over two years.
Dr. Kimberly Gudzune specializes in weight management. During her clinics, patients often complain that their primary care doctor is too harsh about their weight and they want a different doctor. That prompted her study, which looked at the medical records of more than 20,000 patients.
DR. KIMBERLY GUDZUNE: Doctor shopping was 23 percent higher among overweight patients as compared to normal weight; and 52 percent higher for obese patients as compared to those of normal weight.
NEIGHMOND: Gudzune doesn't know why these patients switched doctors so much. But she says other research finds primary care settings can be uncomfortable for overweight patients. Staff can be judgmental. And equipment, like blood pressure cuffs and exam tables, are often too small.
In the study, overweight and obese patients were 80 percent more likely to end up in the hospital ER than normal weight patients.
GUDZUNE: Interestingly, they did not have increased rates of hospitalizations over that same period, which suggests to me that, you know, these patients were using the emergency department potentially for conditions that, you know, really didn't need to go to the emergency room.
NEIGHMOND: Trips to the ER cost far more than visits to a primary care doctor. And for patients, not having a stable doctor can jeopardize their health.
GUDZUNE: Patients who have the same doctor are less likely to need to use the emergency room. They're also more likely to get all of their preventive health screening, such as breast cancer screening and colon cancer screening.
NEIGHMOND: Gudzune says improved communication between doctors and patients could make a big difference not only in patient health but also in helping patients lose weight.
Patti Neighmond, NPR News.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
GREENE: This is MORNING EDITION from NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.